I don't think there is any doubt the two best college players of all-time are Alcindor and Walton (in that order). Even though I believe Walton was a better all-around player, nothing compares to big Lew's skyhook. However, as a passer and defender, I give the edge to Walton. Either way, the ultimate goal of any player in a team sport is to win the game (and championship), and this is where I give the edge to Alcindor.
I don't think there is any doubt the two best college players of all-time are Alcindor and Walton (in that order). Even though I believe Walton was a better all-around player, nothing compares to big Lew's skyhook. However, as a passer and defender, I give the edge to Walton. Either way, the ultimate goal of any player in a team sport is to win the game (and championship), and this is where I give the edge to Alcindor.